The open blogging platform. Say no to algorithms and paywalls.

4 AWS File Systems Compared

What Are Cloud File Systems?

A cloud file system allows users to store and retrieve files in a virtualized environment where resources like servers and networks are pooled and shared among multiple users. This kind of storage system is generally hosted by third-party service providers who charge their customers based on the storage capacity they use.

Cloud file systems can be public, private, or hybrid. Public file systems are typically owned and operated by a third-party provider on a shared infrastructure. Private file systems are dedicated to one organization and are either physically located on-premises or hosted by a third-party provider. Hybrid file systems combine elements of both public and private file systems.

Overview of AWS File System Services

Amazon Web Services (AWS) provides a variety of file system services that meet the diverse needs of businesses. These services range from object storage to block storage and file storage. In this section, we will discuss four AWS file system services: Amazon Elastic File System (EFS), Amazon S3, Amazon FSx for Windows File Server, and Amazon FSx for Lustre.

Amazon Elastic File System (EFS)

Amazon Elastic File System (EFS) is a cloud-based file storage service for applications that run on Amazon Web Services. EFS is easy to use and provides a simple interface through which you can create and configure file systems. It is designed to provide massively parallel shared access to thousands of Amazon EC2 instances, allowing applications to achieve high levels of aggregate throughput and IOPS.

EFS is a scalable file storage solution for both small and large workloads. You can start with a small file system and it will automatically grow to accommodate the increased data over time. EFS is a fully managed service, which means there is no need to worry about the underlying infrastructure or the management of the file system.

EFS is highly available and durable, offering redundancy and backup across multiple Availability Zones. It also supports a wide range of file system operations and can be accessed from multiple Amazon EC2 instances, making it a suitable solution for applications and workloads that require shared file storage.

Amazon S3

Amazon Simple Storage Service (S3) is a scalable, high-speed, web-based cloud storage service designed for online backup and archiving of data and applications on Amazon Web Services. It allows you to store and retrieve any amount of data at any time, from anywhere on the web.

Amazon S3 is designed for 99.999999999% durability and 99.99% availability of objects over a given year. It replicates all data across at least three geographically separated regions and allows for automatic, policy-based archiving to lower-cost storage tiers.

S3 provides comprehensive security and compliance capabilities that meet even the most stringent regulatory requirements. It gives you flexibility in the way you manage data for cost optimization, access control, and compliance.

Amazon FSx for Windows File Server

Amazon FSx for Windows File Server provides a fully managed native Microsoft Windows file system that can be accessed from any Windows-based application. It offers the compatibility and features of a native Windows file system, including full support for the SMB protocol and Windows NTFS, Active Directory (AD) integration, and Distributed File System (DFS).

FSx for Windows File Server is built on Windows Server, providing a wide range of administrative features such as user quotas, end-user file restores, and Microsoft's shadow copy. It also provides automatic backups, encryption, and file system consistency checks.

FSx for Windows File Server is designed to deliver fast, predictable performance with the throughput and IOPS needed to support the most demanding applications. It allows you to scale your file system capacity up or down within minutes as your needs change.

Amazon FSx for Lustre

Amazon FSx for Lustre is a fully managed file system that is optimized for compute-intensive workloads, such as high-performance computing, machine learning, and media data processing workflows. Lustre is a type of parallel distributed file system, generally used for large-scale cluster computing.

FSx for Lustre is seamlessly integrated with Amazon S3, making it easy to process cloud data sets with high-performance file systems. When linked to an S3 bucket, an FSx for Lustre file system transparently presents S3 objects as files and allows you to write results back to S3.

FSx for Lustre is designed for performance, offering sub-millisecond latencies, up to hundreds of gigabytes per second of throughput, and millions of IOPS. It also provides strong read-after-write consistency and allows for massively parallel and distributed processing.

AWS File Systems Compared

Performance Comparison

Let's start with Amazon Elastic File System (EFS). EFS is designed to provide high performance for a broad spectrum of workloads and applications. It scales on-demand to petabytes without disrupting applications, growing and shrinking automatically as you add and remove files. However, it's important to note that performance in EFS is tied to the amount of data stored.

Next, we have the Amazon FSx for Lustre, a fully managed service that provides high-performance file storage. FSx for Lustre is designed for applications that require high-speed data throughput, and it's particularly suited for machine learning, high performance computing (HPC), and media data processing workflows.

Lastly, Amazon FSx for Windows File Server (Amazon FSx) is designed to provide fully managed, highly reliable file storage. It's built on Windows Server, and it delivers fast, scalable, and accessible storage for applications that use the SMB protocol.

Cost Comparison

The cost of cloud storage is a key element of cloud cost optimization. EFS has a simple pay-as-you-go model. You only pay for the storage used, with no minimum commitments or upfront fees. This makes EFS a cost-effective option for businesses with fluctuating storage needs.

On the other hand, FSx for Lustre and FSx for Windows have a different pricing structure. They include the cost for the file system and backup storage, data transfer, and optional features like file system restoration. It's worth noting that FSx for Lustre is specifically optimized for short-term, compute-intensive tasks, hence, it may be more expensive for long-term storage.

Scalability and Flexibility

EFS provides an automatic scaling feature. It adjusts capacity as files are added or removed, eliminating the need to provision and manage capacity. This makes it highly scalable and flexible.

FSx for Lustre, while not as flexible as EFS, scales storage and throughput separately, allowing you to optimize cost and performance. FSx for Windows, on the other hand, offers fixed storage capacities during file system creation but allows for adjustments later.

Ease of Use and Management

Managing cloud storage should be simple and hassle-free. In terms of ease of use and management, all three AWS file systems provide a fully managed experience, reducing the administrative burden.

EFS is easy to use, with seamless integration with AWS management console, CLI, and SDKs. It also offers lifecycle management features that automatically move files to cost-effective storage classes.

FSx for Lustre provides a Lustre-compatible file system, making it easy to move data from existing Lustre file systems. FSx for Windows, being a native Windows file system, integrates seamlessly with Active Directory and other Windows features.

Security and Compliance

EFS, FSx for Lustre, and FSx for Windows all support encryption of data at rest and in transit. They also offer integrated backup and restore capabilities. In terms of compliance, these file systems comply with a wide range of industry standards, including PCI-DSS, HIPAA/HITECH, FedRAMP, EU Data Protection Directive, and FISMA, helping you meet regulatory requirements.

AWS File Systems: How to Choose?

Choosing the right AWS file system depends on your specific needs. EFS offers scalability and cost-effectiveness, making it suitable for businesses with variable data needs. FSx for Lustre is ideal for compute-intensive tasks requiring high-speed data throughput, while FSx for Windows provides a reliable, familiar environment for Windows-based applications.

Remember, the best AWS file system is one that aligns with your performance, cost, scalability, management, and security requirements. Be sure to take these factors into account as you make your decision, and you'll find the AWS file system that perfectly fits your business needs.

Continue Learning